As white smoke signaled the election of Pope Leo XIV, the first American pontiff, celebrations erupted in St. Peter’s Square — but political ripples are already spreading in the U.S. Cardinal Robert Prevost of Chicago, 69, was elected pope on May 8, becoming the first American leader of the Catholic Church. Praise came swiftly from U.S. political leaders, with President Trump calling it a “Great Honor for our Country,” and Vice President JD Vance offering prayers for his leadership. Strained Alignments Despite the fanfare, some MAGA supporters have begun labeling the new pope as “anti-Trump.” Past social media posts from Pope Leo’s verified X account show him resharing criticism of JD Vance and voicing concern about Trump-era immigration rhetoric. One notable repost was a National Catholic Reporter op-ed criticizing Vance’s interpretation of Christian love, following his remarks on Fox News that emphasized prioritizing love for family and country over others. More recently, Pope Leo XIV reshared a Catholic Standard article that condemned jokes made by Trump and El Salvador’s President about the deportation of a Maryland resident, calling on Catholics to question their consciences. A Papacy with Principles While U.S. leaders have celebrated his election, Pope Leo XIV appears unafraid to challenge political views that clash with Catholic teachings on compassion, immigration, and moral responsibility
